5 Comments
User's avatar
Hollis Brown's avatar

why Marx though?

this is what I don’t get. after all the horrors of the 20th century that Marxists countries brought to the world, why do people still advocate for Marx’s version of socialism?

why can’t anyone condemn Marx as a charlatan and advocate for any other form of socialism?

or, God forbid, come up with a new system that isn’t a failed ideology that is almost 200 years old?

(if I had to answer my own question it would be that Marx turns envy and resentment into virtues and it still has a radical chic appeal to the freaks)

Richard Fulmer's avatar

Marx referred to capital as “dead labour, that, vampire-like, only lives by sucking living labour, and lives the more, the more labour it sucks.” But capital is tools, machinery, the means of production. Far from sucking the blood from workers, they make workers far more productive and relieve them of a lot of back-breaking labor.

And those tools are the same means of production that the proletariat would (as part of their historically inevitable role) expropriate and then use according to the processes that evolved under capitalism.

Mad Max's avatar

If you would be happy with being that factory worker with a solid social safety net for life, then socialism is for you.

If you want the opportunity to improve your (and your family’s) lot in life, you don't want socialism. Socialism pursues equity (equality of outcomes) at the expense of equality of opportunity.

Socialism will actually make inequality worse by holding most at the lower rungs on the economic ladder while a very small group will control the top rung and the gap between them will become insurmountable.

I come from a low income family and started out at minimum wage and worked my way up through the skilled trades, into management, and finished my 45 year career as a consulting MEP engineer. I did all of that without a college degree or even a good basic education. During my career I persevered, did without a lot of things my coworkers bought, and saved and invested (early and often). By the time I retired, from my savings and investments, I have a $3M net worth. That could not have happened under socialism.

And the economy today is much better than anytime during my first 30 years of working (ending with the 2008 financial crisis). Inflation and unemployment were much higher than now.

NELSON F CROUCH's avatar

FYI, my Presbyterian church in Washington, DC succeeded in putting me in jail for 27 hours to stop me from protesting its support for so-called "Gender Affirmative Care"--which involves the administration of puberty blockers and sex change operations on our children. I had to attend 10 hearings, take four drug tests, and consent to attend two therapy sessions to deal with my `illness.' My $500,000 lawsuit against the Feds was dropped, on procedural grounds. I failed to get the attention of DoJ bosses who presumably would have seen me as a `hero' rather than a `villain'. I lost my $100,000 suit against the church on the ground that I should have sued the janitor instead! 'The case is on appeal. I would love to share my story--I can send you the briefs if you would like. I believe I am the only American who the `Woke" thought police got put in jail.

I have also written a lengthy `Counter Attack' against the British actor Daniel Radcliff, who played Harry Potter in the films, for betraying J. K. Rowling because of her opposition to the Trans Movement. She enabled him to make $100 million and he sold her out for fear of the Trans Mob. Do you have an idea of how I can get my essay to Ms. Rowling's attention? It has a ten or so page Fantasy of her catching a plane from London to California to save a young fan from castration. You are two of my heroes.

I am in the midst of writing a brief defending Musk from Senator Sanders long held goal of Demonizing our Billionaires and taking a good chunk of their wealth.

I LOVED your Capitalism vs. Socialism Debate--YOU WON!

Keep up the Fight!

The Barbarians are at The Gate.

Regards,

Nelson Crouch 202-445-3105 crouchnelson@gmail.com

Kim Jarvis's avatar

For the past few years, my hubby and I have been watching The Mega-Brands That Built America. It is absolutely fascinating to learn about the entrepreneurs who literally risked everything to pursue their dreams. I do view their stories completely different from how I view these mega brands today though. Now, I view their lobbying efforts as the reason why those same entrepreneurs have it so much harder today. The vast majority of gov't regulation only benefits the corporations (which is designed that way), as it blocks out potential rivals.

I believe it was Milton Friedman who warned us that, as gov't grew, so did the collusion between it and these mega corporations. Marxism is 100% NOT the answer. The only recourse I can think of is to shrink gov't, and overburdensome regulations. But, is that even possible at this stage in the game?