I recently debated a Marxist. Andrew Hartman is a historian and the author of Karl Marx in America, and we spent nearly four hours going back and forth on Marx, capitalism, and American history. We covered a lot of ground. That said, we really hit a wall when the theory got personal.
My wife had the idea to start a cloth diaper business. We’d cloth diapered our son and really liked it, so she designed this neat little product where the Velcro on the front was a pair of little hugging hands. We called them Wee Huggers. We spent a year building that business while I was working at Spike TV and Lisa was home with our son, and we eventually got into 55 stores. Customers loved them. We couldn’t keep them in stock. And we never made a nickel. It was all expense and no profit, because we were paying local seamstresses to sew every one by hand, and every dollar that came in went to them.
So I asked Andrew: were my wife and I workers or capitalists?
Andrew responded that Marx doesn’t really have a box for us. He was more interested in the bigger pattern, the way people get pushed into two great classes of those who own the means of production and those who work for them. That’s a strange blind spot, since our story is how most businesses start. Andrew himself said he isn’t against somebody starting a business on a good idea and could imagine a future socialist society that would allow for that.
I didn’t buy it, and I’ll get to why. But first, the common ground, because there’s a little more of it than either of our camps would like to admit.
Markets, Cronies, and Labor
Andrew said he isn’t against markets. Most socialists aren’t, he told me. Markets have been around since before the days of feudalism. They’re inherent in the human condition. What Marxists object to is something narrower. Capitalism, in the Marxist definition, is when some people own the means of production, and most of the goods in circulation end up controlled by fewer and fewer people. Andrew said he can imagine a market socialism that works very well, and he reminded me that Marxists have historically been as anti-statist as the most rabid libertarian. Most of the Marxists he writes about in the 20th century were deeply critical of the US government for colluding with the biggest, wealthiest corporations. He thinks we’re living at the apex of state capitalism.
I’ll grant him the cronyism, and only the cronyism. Adam Smith talked about this all the time. Get enough powerful business interests in a room and they will start to collude. No libertarian has a perfect answer for how we keep the rules from being rigged in favor of the people who can buy the politicians. Saying “let’s get money out of politics” is just a slogan. Every attempt to do it just increases incumbency, since the current senator with guaranteed access to CNN always has a bigger megaphone than the upstart trying to unseat him.
So we agree that markets are natural and that cronyism is real. That’s about where the agreement ends.
Here’s how Andrew makes the case for Marxism.
A 19th-century worker has to put in a 60- or 70-hour week to earn enough to survive. But over the course of maybe 20 or 30 of those hours, he has created enough value to cover his wages. The rest of the week, his labor is being exploited. That’s why Marx supported reforms like the 10-hour workday. He wasn’t some bomb-throwing revolutionary. Marx actually appreciated, almost celebrated, capitalism for the explosion of productivity and creativity it unleashed after feudalism. He just thought the system that produced all that could have been socialized too, in terms of who controls it and who benefits from it.
That’s the intuitive version, the one most people carry around. Take the Tesla Gigafactory here in Austin. If you’re on that floor assembling Teslas, and Elon is the one making all the money, it’s easy to feel like you’re doing the work and somebody else is keeping the value.
Andrew takes it a step further. For Marx, all value in a capitalist society emerges from labor, but some of it is what he called dead labor. If you own a factory and keep accumulating capital on top of your workers’ labor, 20 years from now you’re still holding capital that came from labor done 20 years ago. Capital, in this view, isn’t a separate thing that competes with labor. It’s labor in stored form. Under capitalism, work gets valued by how much capital it helps someone accumulate, and to Andrew that distorts value in ways that don’t serve humanity.
My problem is that labor alone tells you nothing about value. I can go in my backyard and work real hard building a go-kart with no wheels. I’ve sweated for hours, and I’ve actually destroyed value in any meaningful sense, because it would have been better to leave the raw materials alone. The fact that I labored is irrelevant. Marx is measuring the input instead of the value of the output.
Is Grandma the Bad Guy?
Which brings me back to the diapers.
The problem with Wee Huggers was never demand. It was capital. Making diapers by hand was very expensive. To make any money, we needed to place a large order, something like 10,000 units, so we could have them mass manufactured at a fraction of the cost. On top of that, there was nowhere in the US we could even get that done. My wife talked to textile manufacturers in Newark who told her they paid $25 an hour with full healthcare benefits on day one, and they couldn’t get anyone to even apply. Meanwhile, our crunchy granola mom customers didn’t want anything made in China. They didn’t want to pay $30 a diaper either.
We didn’t end up taking on an investor, but imagine we had. My grandmother is a retiree who has always saved her money. She puts in $100,000 and we sell her 10% of the company. We use it to buy a big batch of inventory that might not sell. If it does sell, the money goes right back into the next batch, which is also at risk. It’s not even going to be enough for my wife and me to make any money. My grandmother could have just put that money in the stock market. There’s a time cost of money, hence interest rates. Now imagine that after ten years of earning nothing, Oprah features us, we’re finally a real business, and we start to hire. Should the employee who shows up on day one, put nothing at risk, and could quit and get another job tomorrow, get a share of the company my grandmother’s savings built?
In every version of Marxism I have heard, my grandmother is now the bad guy. I’m being a little bombastic, but not really.
This is where Marx’s economics really breaks down. In the 1890s, the Austrian economist Eugen von Böhm-Bawerk took Marx’s labor theory of value apart on exactly these grounds. Marx doesn’t account for time. Workers get paid their wages now, before the product is sold, and before anyone knows whether it will sell at all. Someone has to wait, and someone has to bear the risk that the whole thing loses money. The return on capital is the price of that waiting and that risk. Marx’s picture is basically that you show up and you make things. Well, where do you think the equipment came from? Somebody had to save the money and put it at risk to buy it and build it.
Andrew doesn’t think that demolishes the labor theory of value. It demolishes a simplistic one, he says, a version that ignores all the historical and structural ways labor contributes to value. He also pushed back on my grandmother being the villain. He doesn’t see this as a good guy and bad guy story. He says it’s more, “Hate the game, not the player.”
Hate the game if you like, but the game here is entrepreneurship itself. My grandmother putting her money at risk isn’t some side effect of the system. It’s the archetype. He admitted he didn’t have a smoking gun answer to my scenario. What he offered instead was an answer of a different kind. If workers had healthcare through some socialized means, they’d be freer to leave a job and take a chance on a little company like ours. He thinks a lot of capitalism’s bottlenecks make real worker freedom impossible.
This is where I get frustrated with Marxist storytelling. It always leaps to a grand societal architecture that would be better, without ever accounting for who puts the money in first. Andrew’s counter was that I was talking about things on the edges. Little companies like ours aren’t the engine of the economy, he said. The engine is massive industries, giant corporations.
But where do the giant corporations come from? Apple is worth $5 trillion today. It started in a garage, with Steve Wozniak soldering Apple 1 chips to a green board using spare parts from Hewlett-Packard. At every step along the way, in a contract-based individual property order, you can account for every transaction. The investor puts this amount of money at risk and in exchange, if there’s net income, he might get paid back or even get a return on his investment. None of it would have happened at all if he hadn’t put the money in. Capital isn’t some pre-existing factory you can point to. It’s the creation of the factory.
Andrew thinks things like that would keep getting created in a world where workers had more power, especially if they mattered to people. The diapers taught me that the trouble goes deeper than motivation. Most of the decisions in running a business have nothing to do with morality or greed. My wife and I wanted to please our customers. You want a great diaper that makes you happy with your baby. What’s more moral than that? But then we had to decide: should we use fleece or not? That’s a cost-benefit calculation, and the price of fleece is going up and down for reasons that are never fully known. It might be in more demand, or in less supply, or a mix of both. The only way to know is to look at the price, which emerges out of all the haggling and bartering of millions of people. That’s what the old socialist calculation debate was about. Ludwig von Mises and F.A. Hayek argued that without real prices, a socialist economy has no way to make those millions of decisions in a world of scarcity. The system of profit and loss is essentially a giant decentralized calculator, and nobody has found a replacement for it.
Was Our Conversation Worth It?
Here is what I respect most about Andrew. Near the end of our conversation, I asked him which argument he had found the hardest to contend with. He said the economics. The calculation debate and the critiques of Marx from Böhm-Bawerk and the marginalists, he said, are piercing. He’s a trained historian who thinks in terms of grand movements of ideas, and out of everything we discussed, the economics was where he didn’t know if he had a response.
I don’t say that to score a point. Most people on either side of this would never admit that out loud, on camera, to someone they disagree with. Andrew just said it. He still doesn’t buy that entrepreneurship drives our economy, but he was honest about where his argument runs thin. In an argument like this one, that’s rare.
Neither of us expected to convert the other, and neither of us did. What we share is a desire to make this country better, even if each of us thinks the other’s ideas are a path to hell. That’s the nature of a free society.
At the end, I asked Andrew the question I ask every guest: how does he think about his role in the American story? He’s the father of two boys, and he worries about young men who don’t have a place in our society. He teaches a lot of them, and plenty of them feel alienated. Some are conservative, some are apolitical or even nihilistic. He aims to treat every one of them as an individual. To him, the best world is one in which we all can be individuals, but our current arrangements get in the way.
An ironic place to end. The Marxist advocating for the individual.
I think he meant every word of it. And I think if he followed that conviction all the way down, he might end up closer to my view than he’d expect.



why Marx though?
this is what I don’t get. after all the horrors of the 20th century that Marxists countries brought to the world, why do people still advocate for Marx’s version of socialism?
why can’t anyone condemn Marx as a charlatan and advocate for any other form of socialism?
or, God forbid, come up with a new system that isn’t a failed ideology that is almost 200 years old?
(if I had to answer my own question it would be that Marx turns envy and resentment into virtues and it still has a radical chic appeal to the freaks)
Marx referred to capital as “dead labour, that, vampire-like, only lives by sucking living labour, and lives the more, the more labour it sucks.” But capital is tools, machinery, the means of production. Far from sucking the blood from workers, they make workers far more productive and relieve them of a lot of back-breaking labor.
And those tools are the same means of production that the proletariat would (as part of their historically inevitable role) expropriate and then use according to the processes that evolved under capitalism.